Over the past few weeks, there has been a notable deterioration in the correlation between the price action of the Japanese yen and traditional risk-related assets like equities.
This relationship has been utilized and exploited for nearly 18 months as investors and market participants have used the this currency as a gauge for general risk sentiment while others have used it in a kind of cross-market pair trading strategy. Now, traders are left to wonder whether this is a natural recession in a very obvious market link or a sign that the Japanese currency is losing its status as the primary FX safe haven.
The History
Before, we delve into forecasting the future of the yen’s link to safe haven flows; we must first understand why the market has come to expect the correlation to be so strong. Looking back before the current financial and economic crisis, the markets were enjoying a boom period where capital was prevalent, leverage was the standard and rates of return were high. This led seasoned and novice traders alike to the now infamous carry trade. Utilizing leverage, these market participants would borrow in a low interest bearing currency and invest in a higher one. During the height of the boom, the Japanese yen was the primary ‘funding’ currency as the Bank of Japan was forced to keep its benchmark lending rate under 0.50 percent for over a decade thanks to a lack of inflation in the economy. Comforted by the market’s deep liquidity, the flow of capital behind this strategy grew exponentially.
In the summer of 2007, when financial conditions started to deteriorate and the global economy began to yaw, the carry unwinding began. As investors took losses in their other positions, they were forced to liquidate their carry trades to raise cash to buffer dwindling reserves. This matched losses in traditional asset classes to a steady repatriation of yen. Pessimism has proven to be enduring, and the sheer size of the carry trade has supported a long-lasting deleveraging of the once high-flying strategy. Other considerations that have come into play for the yen’s status as a safe haven during the market’s plummet were borne out of economic truisms. Japan is the second largest economy in the world; and therefore, expectations that it would survive and recovery from the shock are greater than some of its counterparts. What’s more, the country is known for large capital surpluses. As a saver nation, liquidity was not considered a problem for Japan. These three considerations served the currency well, until recently.
The Fundamental Break From Safe Haven
The Japanese yen was supported by its well-established carry status and fundamentals for a long time – producing an envious correlation between the currency and the Dow Jones Industrial Average (among other risk related assets). However, with a global recession taking hold and extending the financial slump, we may have seen the market conditions outlast the yen’s staying power.
As the most certain driver for the risk/yen link, the carry trade is also the most ambiguous in its turn against the currency. There will be a natural point to which the built up yield-differential trade will be fully unwound. There were finite funds put into this strategy during the boom years; and therefore, there will be a time when these speculative funds are repatriated. It is difficult (if not impossible) to determine when this deleveraging is complete; but 18 months of forced liquidation and the potential for capital losses in holding a long yen-based cross has at the very least cleared the bulk of the funds. This point has likely come and gone, and speculative momentum behind the move have since taken over for actual flows. Therefore, we merely needed a catalyst to break this trend – and economic health may have been that trigger.
With the carry trade’s influence over the yen waning, its correlation to risk trends was riding on expectations that speculation would maintain its course and Japan’s economy would drawing the market’s capital on its own accord. A critical look at the yen fundamentals now, however, casts the stability of the economy in doubt. Just this past week, the government released its fourth quarter GDP figures which pegged the year-over-year pace of contraction at a staggering 12.7 percent – the sharpest decline since 1974. Such an aggressive decline was not unexpected. Domestic consumption trends have long suffered from a lack of income growth and a consumer base that is renowned for its savings; while foreign demand for Japanese exports has shrunk as the global recession deepens. Far more disconcerting are the forecasts for growth in the world’s second largest economy. The Bank of Japan’s top economist has said first quarter GDP could be “unimaginable;” and growth through 2009 is expected to shrink a record 4.0 percent on an annualized basis according to official forecasts. Add to this the trouble that Japanese policy officials have found in reaching an agreement on much-needed stimulus plans, bailouts and liquidity injections; and both growth and financial health severely undermine safety of funds.
Has The Yen Lost Its Safe Haven Status For Good?
Though we have seen the role of the Japanese yen as a safe haven currency come under strain; does that mean it will lose this global function for good (or at least this market cycle)? Yes and no. As a strict safe haven, there is little to revive the currency’s draw. Most of the carry deleveraging has been spent. There is still something to be said about Japan’s long-standing capital surplus and the economy being the second largest in the world; but this holds little appeal considering the direction it is going. Japan is expected to suffer a far deeper slump going forward and the lack of needed government intervention to this point will likely put the nation behind the recession curve (on which the US, Euro Zone and even the UK are likely ahead on). And, though large surpluses help to establish confidence in liquidity and cash in the economy, this is no longer a key issue for the rest of the world as massive injections of liquidity in the banking system have stabilized overnight lending on a global basis.
On the other hand, while the yen is losing its safe haven status; it is not likely to lose its place in the carry trade. When global growth does turn around and interest rates start to entice macro investors back to the carry strategy, the Japanese target cash rate will no doubt hold near its incredible lows – and market participants know it. With long-lasting deflation and a glut of domestic savings, there is little to drive the benchmark rate higher. In contrast, Australian, New Zealand, the UK, the Euro Zone and even the US (to a lesser extent) have a history of quick recoveries and central banks that are more apt to respond through monetary policy. This means, investors will once again draw funds to invest elsewhere to take advantage of the carry and further enjoy the natural appreciation int eh exchange rate.
Who Will Replace The Yen In The Short Term?
Looking down the line, the return of the carry trade is likely a long time off; so those that were trading the yen as a safe haven will have to find an alternative in the mean time. There are two popular options: the US dollar and Swiss franc. The latter currency has enjoyed the status of carry trade and safe haven for quite some time. As a relatively low-yield currency with a central bank that typically deliberated on rate shifts only once a quarter, the Swiss currency was a natural source for funds. And, with an economy that prizes low taxes on funds and privacy, its safe haven status was secure – that is until recently. Just this past weekend, EU leaders gathered to develop a coordinated plan to answer the ongoing economic crisis; and one of their policy points was identifying and sanction tax shelters like Switzerland. This clearly leaves the franc in a state of limbo. The dollar on the other hand, has seen its safe haven status intensify with time. Though its recession is expected to worsen with time, US policy officials have taken broad steps to turning growth around – likely putting the US well ahead of the curve. This secures interest in the market’s favored risk-free asset: Treasuries. And though Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke has forecasted the US holding its benchmark interest rate at low levels for an extended period, speculators no doubt still expect returns on traditional assets to growth unimpeded with the rebound in investor confidence.
Written by John Kicklighter, Currency Strategist

















